By Guest Correspondent ChoHey, it’s Cho and I’m back with the last Survivor 40 recap of the season! I’m recapping this episode a day late, and I’m so surprised that I haven’t been spoiled yet. It’s such a pain for me to avoid twitter, because I LOVE tweeting so much! If you haven’t checked me out on there, I’d like to think I’m pretty hilarious. And if you didn’t check out last week’s 2 hour episode, you need to read that recap before getting into the whirlwind that is THIS recap!
We start the finale with Jeff zooming in to the viewers. Tonight is definitely different thanks to Miss Rona. Filming from his garage, it’s all very low budget but endearing at the same time. What isn’t low budget is that someone is about to be awarded 2 million dollars. This really has been the greatest season ever! They literally have all 20 Survivors on zoom. Jeff then tells us that they won’t even have a reunion. That’s a huge bummer. Take notes on how to host a reunion from Bravo please.
Surviving The Edge of Extinction
It’s day 35, and it’s time for someone to battle back into the game. Hard to believe that there’s only 4 days left until the game technically ends, right? I think it’s far too late to have another person return, but here we go LET’S GO NATALIE! The challenge is a fence & post obstacle and ends with a race through a ball maze. Natalie gets to skip a lot of the challenge due to her advantages. The music is really intense during the challenge. NATALIE IS STRUGGLING ON THE FIRST SECTION! Wendell, Parvati and Yul are on her tail already. Natalie is completely blowing this challenge, and I just can’t handle this finale starting off like this.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
2020 has fucked us over enough. Wendell, who has arguably been the biggest disappointment this season, is in the lead, and I just can’t. I’m panicking. Natalie suddenly wins her way back in!! She breaks down in tears. We get really touching moments from several people from the edge. They’re all crying and sharing their perspectives. This is incredible. We get even more zoom calls from the Survivors. I’m totally not crying.
Natalie has such a great comeback story, and Tony is threatened by this. Natalie knows she needs to work hard to create drama and dissension. She starts right in by saying Tony is the favorite in the eye of the jury’s eyes. Tony knows that Natalie is in a powerful position, because she can say whatever the fuck she wants and no one can dispute it. Sarah doesn’t think Natalie is as big of a jury threat as she actually is. Tony argues that if Natalie gets to the end, she wins. Sarah doubts how hard she needs to work to prove that she had an equal if not more significant role in her partnership with Tony.
Headed For an Underdog Victory?!
The immunity challenge looks really fun especially with the huge water slide. It’s one of those super cool obstacle courses where you can choose which section you do first. Ben is in a huge lead, but Tony, Natalie and Sarah aren’t far. Ben, Natalie and Tony begin working on their puzzles. Michele is incredibly far behind, but she looks like she’s having fun at least!
Thing is that Michele did this challenge in her original season and easily solved the 3-tier puzzle so there’s still hope. She finally joins everyone to start working. And fuck, just like that, Michele is already AHEAD of the others with her first tier!! Everyone starts looking at Michele’s puzzle and she calls them a bunch of cheaters! We’ve got a race between her and Natalie! Michele quickly gets her second tier and goes on to complete her 3rd winning her second immunity challenge in a row!
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Natalie takes Michele aside in order to bridge some trust with her as someone that is also on the bottom. This is the ultimate underdog alliance right here! Natalie shares her idol with Michele and they scheme on a way of breaking up the majority 4-person alliance of Tony, Sarah, Denise and Ben. Michele is excited that she has an opportunity to actually successfully make a move tonight with the help of Natalie. They both are wary of Tony’s idol, so they start thinking of Ben and Sarah as backup votes.
The Boy Who Cried Wolf
Tony starts scheming about a way of causing a tie vote in case of an idol. He wants to throw 2 votes against Natalie and 2 against Denise, but Ben is against that because he’s trying to value his relationship with Denise. He says last time he didn’t play a good social game, but this time he’s going to honor his allies. Ben and Sarah don’t believe Natalie even has an idol. They are naive. Did they not just see Natalie play 3 advantages in the battle back challenge?! I’m with Tony, I’d be assuming she had all the superpowers at this point!
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
I know some of y’all don’t like Tony, but homie knows this fucking game inside and out. His intuition is telling him the truth, and if he and Ben burn their idols, Sarah ends up a likely target. He tries to convince Sarah that the easiest thing to do is to simply vote Denise out so that they can save their idols at the next round. Sarah is adamant that Natalie doesn’t have an idol and starts yelling at Tony to calm down. She claims that she’s in control and knows what’s going on which means she’s about to be blindsided 5 minutes from now. For once, Tony isn’t just being a paranoid trainwreck.
Tribal Council
Obviously, the focus of this tribal council is Natalie and her threat level in the game since coming back from the Edge of Extinction. Sarah says that her info about Tony being the one most respected by the jury really shook her to her core. She brings up the gender bias because of the backlash she got from winning her season. She was called a bitch, fake and 2-faced while guys who win are called great players. She says she will not be constrained by that gender bias anymore and that guilt has been lifted.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Natalie hopes to use Michele to break up the 4 person alliance. She doubles down on her argument that they are going to let Tony win 2 million dollars if they don’t do anything about it. It’s time to vote. The jury is all cleaned up now by the way. They look great. Natalie plays her idol. We get shocking stares from Sarah, Ben and Denise while Tony says “I told you so! I knew it!” Tony then plays his idol. Ben then plays his idol! Wow. Jeff reads the votes: Natalie, Natalie, Natalie, Natalie, Ben, Ben. We have a 0-0 tie!
Jeff explains that if a tie occurs between Denise and Sarah that they will have to fight it out with fire. This is sad seeing Sarah leave like this. Jeff reads the votes: Denise, Denise and Denise is voted out 4-0?! That was surprising. I guess they thought Denise was a bigger jury threat than Sarah. Denise is just happy that she and she alone will be forever called “The Queen Slayer”.
The Last Hidden Immunity Idol
Tony immediately chastises Ben and Sarah for not listening to him. If they had simply voted out Denise, they would still have two idols in their pockets to use at the final 5. Instead, they burnt two idols and luckily had the votes to take Denise out in a revote. I would be livid if I were Tony. However, he knows that with 3 idols being played in one night, there has to be one rehidden. He literally starts searching in the middle of the night using handmade lanterns to see.Unfortunately for Tony, the sun comes up and now everyone has woken up to start searching for the idol. It’s awkward watching everyone casually search amongst one another. Natalie ends up finding the hidden immunity idol!!
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
The immunity challenge is super boring. All you need to know is that Tony won, and everyone is worried about Natalie having an idol. Tony instructs Sarah to chat with the girls while he hides in the aerial spynest. Sarah leads Natalie to the well and she sees the idol in her sleeve. I’m sure Natalie is pissed, but she plays it off cool and tells Sarah where she found it and that she wants to target Ben. Tony is PISSED. He’s also bruised from sitting uncomfortably in the tree for an hour while he eavesdropped. Ha! Tony says how spot on he is. They target Michele to go home.
Leaving The Game With Friends
Ben and Sarah talk about where the idol will be played, and Ben suddenly tells Sarah that she has permission to write his name down so that she can pad her resume and prove that she wasn’t dragged to the end by Tony. Ben is dead serious and says that she can only go through with this if it means she wins at the very end. Sarah cries. Ben is crying. I’m DEFINITELY not crying! I’ve had an emotional few weeks. I’ve spent all season hating Ben only to now love him. 2020 won’t stop mindfucking me. I’m tired on so many levels. Ben says he’s going to walk away from this season having actual friends unlike last time when he made a lot of enemies.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
They get really heavy during tribal council. This is the best tv show in mankind’s history. Ben is trying to represent his family in a better light by being more positive. Jeremy, who is on the jury and feuded with Ben all season, rolls his eyes. Tony has now won immunity for the 4th time and everyone knows Natalie is going to play an idol. It’s time to vote. I’m intrigued with what Sarah decides. Natalie plays her idol for herself while in tears. Jeff reads the votes: Ben, Michele, Ben, Michele and the last vote is for… Ben! Tony is audibly surprised. Ben really left on a good note.
The Final Decision
We go right into the final immunity challenge which is one of those terrifying feats where they have to drop balls down a shoot and catch them with one hand! I always sweat during this challenge. Jeff reminds us that Michele is the only one who won the final challenge in their season. He also tells us that everyone that has won this specific challenge has gone on to win the game. Tony is first out! My palms are sweaty, come on Michele! Sarah is out. You have to respect them both as competitors. Natalie keeps having close calls, while Michele has been super zen. Natalie pulls out the win!
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Natalie now has a lot to think about in terms of who to bring with her and who to force into a fire making competition. Michele seems to easily make fire while Tony struggles a lot. He’s doing more talking and should be practicing more often. Natalie’s goal is to get rid of Tony before the final tribal council. She’s afraid that if she has Sarah beat him that it will only strengthen Sarah’s case to win. Her other option is to make Michele compete against Tony. Michele says that winning a fire making challenge may be what she needs to do in order to win in the end.
An Epic Fire-Making Challenge
We get to tribal council, and Natalie relishes the fact that she has the last decision to make in the game after being voted off first. Sarah cries as she says that she wants to make fire against Tony. Michele also says she’s been practicing all day and wants nothing more than to beat Tony. Then, Tony calls Natalie out on why she won’t make fire against him while Michele and Sarah are clamoring to prove themselves to the jury. This could be a mistake for Natalie in front of the jury. Chris paved the way on how to win from the Edge.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Natalie makes Sarah and Tony compete. We’re about to see the end of “Cops R Us”. Tony gets a tiny bit of flame started and is now nurturing it. Sarah then gets her flame going. This is a competition! Sarah’s flame is so close, but then it goes down. Now Tony’s is getting higher after diminishing prior. Sarah is back in it. THIS IS THE CLOSEST FIRE MAKING CHALLENGE EVER! Tony wins!! Him and Sarah embrace and are in complete tears. Tony is ugly crying and refusing to look at the camera. If you’re taking a drink every time Cho cries, then you probably need your stomach pumped by now.
Final Days
I honestly don’t care who wins at this point. I think all three left are MORE than deserving in different ways. I haven’t had a season like this where I would honestly be completely satisfied with anyone winning. I do prefer Tony at this point, but let’s see how it all plays out! They each enjoy the breakfast and reflect on their own accomplishments. Tony makes the case that he’s good at all aspects of the game while Natalie’s strength was mostly challenges and Michele was the social game. He wants to join Sandra as Survivor royalty and be the King of Survivor.
Outwit
At Tribal Council, Denise wants to know what their social missteps were. Natalie says she over relied on her superficial value to others instead of actively forging alliances and relationships. Michele says her weak point was not having a majority alliance despite having many strong individual allies. Nick has the audacity to be bitter towards Tony. Jeremy as well. Tony calls them out on their hypocrisy in that they were gunning for him as well.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Rob wants to know why Natalie isolated herself from him, Amber, Ethan, Yul, and Wendell when they are jury members whose votes she needs?! This social faux pas is news to us, which is why we need 15-20 minute episodes of Extinction EVERY week on CBS All Access. Natalie explains that her acquisition of advantages the last week on the edge created a rift with her relationships, because she was trying to be secretive.
Wendell wants Michele to explain her outwit portion of the game. She explains that she didn’t have a majority alliance to support her or protect her. Instead, she was forced to be adaptable and move within the cracks every week. Ben says that as a fellow “controversial winner”, he understands why Michele won her season and is proud of her accomplishments in this one.
Outplay
Wendell wants to know everything Natalie won. She says if the social aspect of outwit is her weak point in the game, this is where she definitely shined. She begins to list them all off: hidden immunity idol, safety without power, steal an advantage, extortion, the disadvantage twist, log challenge, coconut challenge and then the battle back challenge advantages. Whew! Natalie says she was still actively playing the game and impacting everyone else throughout the season. Michele says winning immunity during a clutch round enabled her to see another round which could dramatically change the dynamic.
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
Rob calls Natalie out on her not stepping up to the fire making challenge against Tony. She says that Natalie really wanted to decimate the majority alliance, and she’s at peace being the one to accomplish that. Michele says that the edge was great for her, because her allies were all there to support her. She brings up the fact that she was gifted the most fire tokens in the game which speaks well of her ability to make friends.
Outlast
Natalie says that she did what seemed impossible: making it to the end despite being voted out first and dismantling this season’s most powerful alliance. Michele says she only went to 6 tribals in her original season compared to 15 out of 19 this season. She’s not a beast in challenges like Natalie and she can’t build spyshacks like Tony, but she can be herself and win the hearts of others. Tony says his work ethic is unmatched despite the fact that no one ever wrote his name down this season.
New Royalty Is Crowned
The jury then starts to congratulate each of them about their games and how worthy they all are before getting ready to vote. Sophie looks like she’s on her death bed or simply needs a nap. It’s probably both. This is the largest jury ever. Rob votes for Tony. Parvati votes for Natalie. Tyson votes for Natalie. Nick votes for Michele I think, but it isn’t shown. Ben votes for Tony. Jeff has everyone on zoom in real time. Fuck, Michele is HOT! They all bring their families into the camera. Jeff starts to read the votes: Tony, Natalie, Natalie, Tony, Natalie, Tony, Natalie, Tony 5-5 tie with Michele getting 0. Tony, Tony, Tony, Tony, and Tony is officially the King of Survivor!
Click Here For More Survivor Recaps!
So what do we think everyone?! I literally cried at least 3 times tonight. What a beautiful show. I wish Michele had at least received a single vote, but I’m happy with Tony being crowned the King of Survivor. What did you think? Let me know in the comment section below! Please do me a HUGE favor and check out my personal blog where I review everyday items that could add massive value to your life!
Great recap, great season! Really glad Tony won, he played great. I was disappointed that the people still in the game did not get to buy any advantages for the immunity challenges or immunity idols. Other than Denise buying some rice and people buying advantages sent from extinction, they seemed to have very little value to those still in the game.
Ooops, I’m referring to the Fire Tokens.
I loved Tony winning. I thought the fire tokens held some weight for those in the game, but most of it was best used for those on the edge of extinction.
I hate tony.. but with that being said he did play a great game. I wanted to see Natalie win especially since she was first voted out and then came back at the end and found the hidden immunity idol and won the last challenge but I think her not going against Tony in the fire challenge is what ultimately caused her the loss. I really wanted to see an all women final three, maybe next time!
How can you hate someone who is open and kind? That’s a reflection on you.
An all women final 3 would have been cool. That’s definitely what Natalie wanted, but Tony is great. I loved seeing him dominate. Not a single vote cast against him. I think if you win the final immunity challenge coming from the Edge, you HAVE to go to fire regardless. Chris set the tone with that one.
Thanks for your comment!! <3
I wouldn’t have gone against him either; for what? Why take that chance? She didn’t have anything else to prove to the others. Rob was just mad “he” didn’t get back in the game. Even though she played an excellent game….Rob wasn’t gonna vote for Natalie anyway or from the beginning.
I don’t think I would have gone up against him either in fire, but Chris set the tone with his major move to go to fire. I feel like it’s almost a pre-requisite to winning if you come back from the Edge. You literally can’t play a more perfect game than Natalie did.
I truly believe that Tony won the game when he avoided the extortion penalty and orchestrated the blindside of Sophie. I’m by no means a Natalie fan going back to her stints on The Amazing Race and being such an unlikable character. Also not a fan of the Edge twist as there were far too many people and extremely dislike someone getting back in the game at such a late stage. Thankfully the “Ponderosa” videos are available on YouTube including one with a look back at the Amber/Boston Rob relationship. I got caught up this morning and well worth the time to view.
**Ponderosa is where a survivor that makes the jury goes once voted off. The Denise, Ben and Lucina (Sarah) videos are more typical of seasons past.
Thanks KMac for the Ponderosa video info. I will definitely check it out. A great season and loved the fire token twist. Thanks Cho for the great recaps and looking forward to next season as this virus finally lessens.
Wait there are Ponderosa episodes for THIS SEASON? How can that be? They were on EOE?
Ponderosa picks up with everyone arriving to Ponderosa after the battle back competition
Thanks! I didn’t think they would have it this year!
I so look forward to twatching when folks see themselves in the mirror for the 1st time or if someone not well liked arrives. This season it’s all kumbaya moments.
Um after on of the best seasons EVER, I am not sure what you are looking forward to.
100% agree with you about Tony’s best moves this game. I happen to really like Natalie though. She’s rough around the edges for sure though.
I will gladly be checking out the ponderosa videos! Thanks for the tip!
Great recap Cho! This season was awesome in so many ways. I was rooting for Natalie to win but I’m also happy Tony won. I think they should have split the win because they each played an amazing game, just not in the same locations.
Rob got it right when he said she almost had the perfect game but she should have gotten Tony out, I think even she would agree. We didn’t get an all-women final three but we did get an all-Jersey final three ?
I’m going to check out Ponderosa, I was missing it all season so thanks for that KMac!
I’m also wondering if 16/17 year olds are really eligible to play next seasonal if Probst was just kidding.
Watching teenagers play will be really interesting. You think they’re trying to focus on bringing in a younger audience? It could be a total disaster. I think of Pump Rules and how much I hated that cast after only one season. Teens are just pretty horrible people overall, no? We were all a teenager. Please don’t tell me I’m crazy for saying that. lol
Another great season of recaps Cho, thanks so much!
Rob pissed me off with the bs about Nat should have made fire against Tony. For 2 million? Battle back from the Edge after being there the longest, win and strategize advantages, go back late in the game and make it to the end only to lose at fire? Get the fuck outta here MARIANO, lol.
The vote was everything Sarah gave lip service only to about gender bias and reminds me of my teen age 70’s poster of Ginger and Fred – who matched every dance step but was wearing heels and dancing backwards.
Thanks a lot Aud. There’s ton of debate about whether Natalie should have competed against Tony or not. I feel like Chris from the original EoE set a precedence with his never seen before move.
I was really pleased with how everything turned out. I think Mariano was just a little jealous that Natalie beat his ass so badly on EoE…
Not just a great season, but the best final episode ever! The planning, the drama, Boston Rob crying, the fire contest, the first one voted out making it to the final three? The whole team congratulating them on how well they did? I would have loved to see Natalie win, but after seeing Tony celebrate with hits family my heart grew three sizes that day. Thanks for such a great season Jeff and Burnett, and thank you for your recaps Cho!
I cried so much omg. What a great finish to an amazing season. Everything happened the way it was supposed to.
Thanks for the great recap Cho!! You’re right, Survivor is the best show on TV. I was disappointed that all of my fave players were voted out early, but I was still entertained until the very end. I’m hoping that because of the nature of Survivor being an isolated game, that they can keep filming during the outbreak? Besides all of the death and economic destruction, a big fear of mine is that we are going to have a huge gap in new productions because no one can film.
I’m happy for Tony… I can never figure out if he is for real or not… but I do like him. I like Natalie as well, it just doesn’t feel right to me that somebody can come in at the very end of the season and possibly win, I hate that twist. Michelle is a great social and physical player, but just never really stood out of the pack for me. I don’t even remember her in her original season.
Looking forward to the next season, whenever that is! Stay safe!
Thanks so much for commenting, Kyle. I appreciate you for reading here. I’m not sure what exactly they can do while Miss Rona is here. The production teams are pretty huge.
Tony is a buffoon, but he’s lovable. Looking forward to seeing what happens next. Check out my Cho Does Reno posts in the meantime!
I think Ben telling Sarah to vote him out was a mistake, if he stayed then Sarah, Tony and Ben would of had a chance to make it to F3. Tony still would of won, but I don’t know, I just think it was a mistake.
I didn’t watch Natalie’s season, so I really wasn’t rooting for her, especially since she was voted out first. What I will say is that she is a very strong and willful player, very impressive, all 3 should be proud to make it to F3.
I really do not like this idea of someone coming back at the end and winning like Chris did. I also didn’t like that all the old school players were voted out early and lived miserable, basically starving on the EoE. I also would of liked to see more Ethan, Yul etc. playing the game. It should of been S40, Old School Winners Only. Ha!!
Overall it was a very good, touching, funny and entertaining season. I love them all, including Ben. This man just wants some friends, just not Adam. lol Who knows maybe they will be friends too.
Tony deserves the win, c’mon now he almost died in the spy nest, hehe. He is funny. He played the best game in my opinion.
I think Natalie and Michelle looked stunning in the finale at home.
All Survivor girls are gorgeous, inside and out. I couldn’t handle sleeping in my backyard overnight, so props to all of our winners and looking forward to many more.
Thank you Cho for the recaps. You’re a Dollface. <3
Well the thing is that they incorrectly thought that Sarah would be the target. Ben’s move makes no sense from a game perspective, but it wasn’t a game move at all. I’m glad he left on a good note, because I was really disliking him for the majority.
It’s easy to judge the EoE twist from our couches. Someone coming in after being “out” doesn’t seem right to me either, but then you have to define what it means to be out of the game. I’d like to think that I would base my vote not on the twist but the merits of the person playing within the confines of that particular game. Definitely easier said than done though.
I was sad to see the old schoolers picked off, but everything happened for a reason, and I’m happy with the outcome! Thanks so much for reading and commenting this season.
Be sure to check out my Cho Does Home Reno posts in between Survivor seasons!
100%. I love your posts!! Be well.